DeTAXify
yourFUTURE
A division of Meridian Point Advisors
www.meridianpointadvisors.com

← The Learning Center

401(k) vs. IUL: Which should I choose?

By Mark Nenno, licensed insurance agent · 8 minute read

If you're saving for retirement, you've probably been told to max out your 401(k). You may also have heard that an Indexed Universal Life (IUL) policy can give you tax-free income in retirement. So which one deserves your money?

Here's how a properly structured, fully funded IUL stacks up against a 401(k), where each one wins, and why the best answer for many families isn't one or the other.

The short answer: If your employer offers a match, contribute enough to your 401(k) to get the full match first. That's free money no other account can beat. After that, an IUL can be a strong place for additional savings if you want tax-free retirement income, have 15 or more years until retirement, and can fund the policy consistently.

How a 401(k) works

A traditional 401(k) lets you contribute part of your paycheck before income taxes. Your money is invested in funds you choose, usually a mix of stock and bond funds, and it grows tax-deferred.

The catch comes later. Every dollar you withdraw in retirement is taxed as ordinary income, at whatever tax rates exist then. Withdrawals before age 59½ generally carry a 10% penalty on top of income tax, with some exceptions. And once you reach your required minimum distribution (RMD) age, currently 73 for most people, the IRS requires you to start withdrawing each year whether you need the money or not.

Many employers now offer a Roth 401(k) option too, which works the opposite way: you contribute after-tax dollars and qualified withdrawals come out tax-free.

How a properly structured IUL works

An IUL is permanent life insurance with a cash value account. When it's designed for savings, the death benefit is kept as low as the tax rules allow and the policy is funded close to the maximum. That puts more of each premium dollar into cash value and less into insurance costs. This is what people mean by "properly structured" and "fully funded."

Your cash value earns interest based on a market index like the S&P 500, with a floor (often 0%) that protects you from market losses and a cap that limits your gains in strong years. In retirement, you can access the cash value through policy loans, which are generally not taxed as income as long as the policy stays in force.

Side by side

Traditional 401(k)Properly structured IUL
Taxes going inPre-tax (lowers your taxable income today)After-tax dollars
Taxes coming outTaxed as ordinary incomeGenerally tax-free through policy loans, if managed correctly
Employer matchOften availableNone
Market lossesYour balance can drop when the market dropsFloor protects cash value from index losses (fees still apply)
UpsideFull market growth, no capLimited by a cap and participation rate
DownsideFull exposure to market drops, and losses must be made up before your balance grows again0% Floor means index losses don't reduce your policy's cash value.
Contribution limitsAnnual IRS limitNo IRS dollar cap, but funding limits apply to keep tax advantages
Access before 59½Usually a 10% penalty plus income taxNo age-based penalty, but surrender charges apply in early years
Required withdrawalsYes, starting at RMD ageNone
CostsFund and plan fees, usually lowerInsurance costs and policy fees, sometimes higher
Life insuranceNoneDeath benefit generally paid income-tax-free to your beneficiaries

Where the 401(k) wins

The employer match. If your company matches 50% or 100% of what you put in, that's an instant return no insurance policy or investment can offer. Always get the full match. No company match on your 401(k)? Then its biggest advantage is off the table, and a properly structured IUL deserves a closer look, especially if tax-free income in retirement matters to you.

Lower costs and full upside. A 401(k) has no insurance charges, and in a strong market you keep all of the growth instead of being capped.

A tax break today. Traditional contributions lower your taxable income now, which helps most if you expect to be in a lower tax bracket in retirement. However, many prominent economists believe that taxes will be much higher in the future.

Where a properly structured IUL wins

Tax-free income later. 401(k) withdrawals add to your taxable income in retirement, which can also make more of your Social Security benefits taxable. Properly managed IUL loans don't count as income.

Protection from market losses. A bad market year within 5 years before or during retirement can do damage to a 401(k) that can be unrecoverable. But the floor on an IUL means you are protected from market losses, and so an index drop doesn't reduce your cash value.

No required withdrawals and no age-59½ rule. You decide when to take money out and how much.

No income limits. High earners who can't contribute directly to a Roth IRA can still fund an IUL.

Life insurance built in. Your family is protected while you're building savings, and you get to leave behind a tax free legacy to your heirs.

Why many people use both

Nobody knows what tax rates will look like in 20 or 30 years, but we believe that tax rates must go up if our economy is going to survive. If all of your retirement money sits in a traditional 401(k) or IRA, every dollar you take out is exposed to whatever those rates turn out to be. Having money in a tax-free bucket gives you ultimate flexibility. In retirement, you can decide each year how much to pull - putting you in control.

A common order of operations looks like this:

  1. Contribute to your 401(k) up to the full employer match.
  2. Build an emergency fund, so you won't need to tap long-term savings for surprises.
  3. Find a reputable, licensed insurance agent to help you design and fund a properly structured IUL.

When an IUL isn't the right move

An IUL is a long-term commitment. It's usually not a fit if you need the money within the next several years, can't commit to steady premiums, or aren't yet capturing your full 401(k) match. Policies also need regular reviews, especially once you start taking loans, to make sure they stay healthy.

See how the numbers compare for you

Every situation is different. In a free 20-minute call, we'll look at what you're saving now, what your goals and needs are and whether adding an IUL to your financial plan makes sense. If it doesn't, I'll tell you.

Let's Chat